
Episode 131: The Life and World of Saint Patrick
The real Saint Patrick lived during the 400s, and left behind two famous documents. In this episode, we learn about his career and the time and place in which he lived.
Saint Patrick’s Confession and Letter to Coroticus
Gold Sponsors
David Love
Aksel Gundersen Kolsung
Andy Olson
Andy Qualls
Asher DeLarme
Bill Harris
Christophe Mandy
Eugene Beye
Jeremy Hanks
John David Giese
KelleyGr
Laurent Callot
Maddao
Mike Roach
ml cohen
Nate Stevens
Olga Gologan
Steve baldwin
Silver Sponsors
Alexander D Silver
Andreu Andreu i Andreu
Boaz Munro
Charlie Wilson
David Macher
Devri K Owen
Ellen Ivens
Evasive Species
Ezio X
Hannah
Jennifer Deegan
John Weretka
John-Daniel Encel
Jonathan Thomas
Julius Barbanel
Michael Sanchez
Morten Rasmussen
Parodysbird
rebye
Susan Hall
Taylor Boudreaux
Top Clean
Ukko
Sponsors
Carl-Henrik Naucler
Joseph Maltby
Robert
Stephen Connelly
A Chowdhury
A. Jesse Jiryu Davis
Aaron Burda
Abdul the Magnificent
Ahmed Malik
Alex Metricarti
Andrew Dunn
Andrew Verras
Ariela Kilinsky
Basak Balkan
Bendta Schroeder
Benjamin Bartemes
Brian Conn
Carl Silva
Carolyn Sabol
Cat Peterson
Charles Hayes
Chief Brody
Chris Auriemma
Chris Brademeyer
Chris Tanzola
Christopher Centamore
Chuck
Cody Moore
Daniel Stipe
David
David Stewart
Denim Wizard
Dominic Klyve
Elizabeth Lowe
Elliot Cole
Eric
Eric McDowell
Erik Trewitt
Anonymous
Evan Nelson
Fawad Zakariya
Francine
Friederike Otto
FuzzyKittens
Garlonga
Hillary Drake
J.W. Uijting
James Breslin
James McGee
Jason Davidoff
Jay Cassidy
JD Mal
Jillyp
Joan Harrington
joanna jansen
Joe Dudley
John Barch
John Sanchez
Jonathan B Whitmore
Joran Tibor
Joseph Flynn
Josh Stegmaier
Joshua Edson
Joshua Hardy
Anonymous
Kathrin Lichtenberg
Kathy Chapman
Kyle Pustola
Anonymous
Lat Resnik
Laura Ormsby
Le Tran-Thi
Leonardo Betzler
Lexi Mayhew
Mélanie Ruelens
Maria Anna Karga
Mark Griggs
MarkV
Matt Hamblen
Maury K Kemper
Michael
Michael Gose
Mike Beard
Mike Sharland
Mike White
Mr Jim
Nassef Perdomo
Nicholas Stern
noah brody
Oli Pate
Oliver
Olivia Fay
Paul Camp
Peter Goldstein
purden@verizon.met
Richard Greydanus
Riley Bahre
Robert Auers
Rosa
Ryan Booth
Ryan Goodrich
Ryan Shaffer
Ryan Walsh
Shaun
Shaun Walbridge
Sherry B
Simone Anders
Sonya Andrews
Sophie
Starshell
Stephen Paarlberg
Steve Grieder
Steven Laden
Stijn van Dooren
Stuart Sherman
Sue Nichols
susan butterick
Ted Humphrey
Thomas Bergman
Thomas Leech
Tim Rosolino
Tod Hostetler
Todd William Armitstead
Tom Wilson
Torakoro
Troy
Vale
vika
Vincent Vandeven
William Coughlin
William King
William Quill
Zak Gillman
Zita Farkas
Other Sponsors
too many to list
Today, Saint Patrick is a gigantic figure in cultural history, and a patron saint of Ireland. In spite of Saint Patrick’s Day, though, and green beer, and colorful hagiographic legends involving snakes, the real Patrick, a Romano-British churchman who emigrated to Ireland in the twilight of the western empire, was a much more impressive person than the Saint Patrick of miracle stories that were later made up about him. In his surviving writings which we will look at today, Patrick is many things – modest, stressed out, full of conviction, embattled, and most of all, disarmingly plainspoken and honest in an era during which Latin language Christian theology was increasingly given to florid rhetoric and hyperbole. Patrick, in short, comes across as just a regular Christian dude, albeit with an oddly fearless tenacity, and in all of Late Antique history, there’s just no one else like him.
Let’s begin by discussing some very basic stuff about Saint Patrick. In spite of the substantial primary sources we have from Patrick himself, we don’t know precisely when he lived. He had a long life – we know this from an anecdote in his Confession, and a lot of that life likely took place during the first half of the 400s. The next very basic thing to understand about Saint Patrick is that although he was absolutely instrumental in spreading Christianity in Late Antique Ireland, Christianity already existed there before he ever set foot on the island, and a Christian bishop had served there before Patrick did. Today, Patrick is the most famous evangelist to have brought Christianity to Ireland, but he wasn’t the first, and in his own writings, he certainly doesn’t purport to be a lone hero.
The next thing to understand about Patrick is to get a sense of how he thought about himself. The opening of his Confession pretty immediately tells us that we are not dealing with an egotistical person. He writes, “I am Patrick – a sinner – the most unsophisticated and unworthy among all the faithful of God.”1 These are not self-aggrandizing words, and in general, Patrick comes across in his own writings not as self-consciously saintly and important, but instead as a stubborn partisan of order during a period that was tending toward a state of disorder. Like many Christians who weathered the decline of the western Roman empire, Patrick believed he was seeing around him the signs of the end of the world. Today, when we think about Patrick and European history, we tend to think of Patrick as living at the beginning of things, but Patrick himself thought the opposite. Like many churchmen of his generation, Patrick took the New Testament’s apocalypticism seriously, and his sense that the end of the world was coming was part of what drove him to convert Irish polytheists to Christianity – he wanted to do so before it was too late. Ireland, to Patrick, was the actual edge of the inhabited earth, and as he delved deeper and deeper into the remoter parts of the island over the course of his career, he had the sense that he was bringing Christianity’s proselytizing mission to its geographical terminus point, at the end of the world in more ways than one.
Speaking of the edge of the earth, it’s probably best to address the miracle story about the snakes sooner rather than later, just to get it out of our heads. Around the year 1200, the English chronicler of saint’s lives Jocelin of Furness wrote a biography of Saint Patrick. And in this biography is the following passage:
[T]he most excellent [Patrick]. . .aided of the angelic aid. . .gathered together from all parts of the island [of Ireland] all the poisonous creatures into one place; then compelled he them all unto a very high promontory. . .and by the power of his word he drove the whole pestilent swarm from the precipice of the mountain headlong into the ocean. O eminent sign! O illustrious miracle!2
It’s a neat story, and an etiological tale for why there really are no snakes in Ireland. But it’s also completely made up, and it’s one of a number of miraculous feats that Patrick accomplishes in Jocelin of Furness’ fanciful biography. Ireland was never a natural habitat for snakes in the first place, and their lack of presence there can be attributed to glaciation and continental drift, rather than a Christian person momentously bellowing sacred words there during the 400s CE. The real Saint Patrick, as we’re about to see, would have found it amusing and a little bit frustrating that the most famous historical anecdote about him is a fairytale, considering how much he accomplished in real life.
Throughout the bulk of this episode, we’re going to set the miracle stories aside, for the most part, and see how much we can learn about Patrick’s life and times from his primary writings. Toward the end of this show, though, I’ll tell you a bit about the enormous corpus of fiction that Saint Patrick inspired throughout the later Middle Ages, because even if this body of work was fiction, it was fiction undertaken with reverence for Patrick, genuine interest in the past, and a lot of literary verve, too. So let’s start with actual history, begin at the beginning, and go back to the year 400 CE.
Around 400, a number of people we’ve met in our podcast were alive and at work. Saint Augustine and Saint Jerome were working overtime to shape the future of the Catholic church with their theological writings. Around 400, the late Latin poet Rutilius Namatianus, on the contrary, was grinding his teeth at the thought of Christianity causing energetic young Roman people to buck the vigorous old traditions of the empire and throw their lives away in monasteries. Around 400, pagan literature was still booming – Heliodorus’ Aethiopica, completed some time during the previous century, signaled the high-water mark of the ancient Greek novel, and somewhere down in Egypt, a brainiac named Nonnus was preparing to write the longest of all classical epics, even though hardly anyone today reads the gigantic, fifth-century Dionysiaca. And right around 400, one of the most important medieval books went into circulation – in roughly 397, the Roman writer Sulpicius Severus published the Life of Saint Martin, a text that would, like other early hagiographies, influence the way that Christianity chronicled its saints for ever after. And into this swirl of paganism and Christianity, up in faraway Britannia, a baby was born to an upper-class Roman family – a baby named Patricius.
Patrick’s Childhood and the Twilight of Roman Britain
Patricius, or Saint Patrick, was born into an aristocratic Roman family very roughly around the year 400. By this year, following the Edict of Thessalonica in 380, the Roman empire had not only named Christianity as its official religion. It had also announced one specific kind of Christianity as its official religion, in spite of the great many Arian Christians, and Christians of other sects living in the empire at that time. There were doctrinal issues at stake with the Edict of Thessalonica. Nicene Christians believed that the father, son, and holy spirit are all coequal and coeternal, unlike in Arianism, in which Jesus is younger than, and subordinate to, Yahweh. But the edict’s prohibition of other forms of Christianity was also part of a culture war between a newly partnered church and state on one side, and barbarian factions of the population on the other – Goths and Vandals, most importantly – who practiced Arianism. After 380, internal barbarian groups in the empire, although they were Christians, were branded as heretics by official policy. Within a generation after 380, these barbarian groups had torn much of the western Roman empire apart.Around the time Patrick was young, between 402 and 410, Gothic military forces invaded the Italian peninsula three times, and on the third, they managed to sack Rome. During the same decade, specifically in 406, a different group of barbarians, this one made up of Vandals, Alans, and Suebi, crossed over the Rhine and into Gaul. As 406 dragged into 407, the despoliation of the Italian peninsula and Gallic provinces led to Roman troops in Britannia not being paid. There were about 6,000 Roman soldiers stationed up above the English Channel, and as you can imagine, an uncompensated, battle-hardened military force is a volatile thing to have in an imperial province. These 6,000 troops were under the command of a Roman general, who has in hindsight been named Constantine III. Constantine III declared himself Roman emperor in 407 with the support of the disgruntled soldiery of Brittania. In search of plunder, he crossed the channel to Gaul in 407, taking with him the Roman military men stationed in Britannia, and, after a brief rise, during which he was named co-emperor with Honorius, Constantine III fell victim to the roiling Roman civil wars of the 410s, having, among other honors, earned the distinction of depopulating Britannia of fighting men during a very dangerous period of late Roman history.
It’s hard to imagine what Romano-Britains like Saint Patrick were thinking in the year 410. Britannia had been largely under Roman control since the 40s CE. And famously, when the city of Rome was sacked in 410 CE, the Roman emperor Honorius is said to have dispatched letters to prominent cities in Britannia, “counselling them to be watchful of their own security,” in the words of the historian Zosimus, writing around the year 500.3 In other words, the emperor of Rome told Britannia, in the year 410, “Good luck up there. Help is not on its way.” The history of fifth, sixth, and seventh century Britain and Ireland is at once extremely pivotal and poorly documented. There are semilegendary accounts of the foundation of Kent, Sussex, and Wessex, and the monk Gildas and historian Bede offer narratives of how a bygone king of Britons summoned Germanic forces to ally with them in a war against other barbarians. But one thing that we can understand with reasonable accuracy about fifth century Britain is its ecclesiastical order. So let’s zoom in from the grand sweep of late Roman history, and consider Christianity in Brittania, and how it worked there.
Patrick banishes the snakes from Ireland in a mosaic on the facade of the Cathedral of St. Patrick in El Paso. The apocryphal story became the single anecdote about Patrick that most people know today. Photo by Lyricmac.
Roman Britain was not an egalitarian society. Accordingly, although Christianity did a lot of good in the twilight of the Roman empire and very early Middle Ages, Roman Christianity in Britannia was not an egalitarian affair. Saint Patrick was born into a wealthy family that owned land, and held powerful public offices. His Latin name, Patrcius, literally comes from the word “patrician,” or “aristocrat.” His family was also installed in the Christian church, whose highest offices were generally held by Roman noblemen who knew how to politick and use soft power. By the end beginning of the 400s, participation in the church increasingly meant power and access to a network. Participation in the church also meant tax breaks.
Patrick’s father, Calpurnius, was a deacon, and his grandfather, Potitus was a priest. Since the time of the first Christian Roman emperor Constantine, the clergy had been exempt from certain kinds of taxes. Patrick’s father Calpurnius was not only a deacon, but also an official in charge of collecting imperial taxes. Calpurnius’ office was hereditary, and so at birth, young Patrick would have been expected to join the clergy and enjoy flourishing within an insider circle of wealthy Romans minimizing their tax burdens, his position as a decurion, or city counsel member, making him an arbiter of money and law from birth.
From what you’ve heard so far, the church of Roman Britannia in about 400 CE sounds like a morally murky old boy’s club more rooted in profit and secret handshakes than in piety. But of course, the clergy of any age is always diverse, encompassing everyone from the genuinely devout to the morally reprehensible, and considering the path that Saint Patrick eventually took, his father and grandfather may indeed have been men of deep and sincere religious convictions.
We don’t know exactly where Saint Patrick grew up. It would have been somewhere on the west coast of Britain, close to the Irish Sea, or Saint George’s Channel, or Bristol Channel, considering something that happened to him when he was young, which we’ll get to in a moment. While we don’t know precisely where Patrick grew up, archaeology of Roman towns in the provinces can furnish us with the basics of what Patrick would have seen around him during his earliest years. Romans used grid systems and other standard features when building towns, their towns often built atop older settlements. His town, which he calls Bannaventa Berniae in his autobiography, would have been relatively small and walled, and equipped with a bathhouse and market area where the public congregated and sought goods, socialization, and entertainment. There were likely guard towers, and a hodgepodge of townhouses of various sizes for the wealthier citizens. And in Patrick’s town of Bannaventa Berniae, wherever it was, there would have been a very modern, newfangled building that symbolized the changing times. This would have been a Christian church.
Some of the other late antique writers we’ve met in our podcast lived and thrived out in Roman provinces during the gradual Christianization of Europe. The poet Ausonius in the 400s, and the poet Venantius Fortunatus in the 500s, though the first was a pagan and the second a Christian, were both Gallic Latin authors who passed their days in the drowsy villas and markets of provincial Rome’s twilight. Saint Patrick’s boyhood town would have been a similar one – a comfortable but somewhat backward borough at a remove from the big cities of Londinium and Camulodunum. The typical Roman country villa, for the aristocracy, was a cozy place. By the time of Saint Patrick, artwork dedicated to pagan gods was being replaced with Christian iconography, but otherwise, patrician country life went comfortably onward like it had for a long time.
Patrician country life, throughout Roman imperial history, was a theme with variations. When we look at a map of the Roman empire at any given century of its history, we often assume that territories Romans conquered became Roman, and that was that. However, what actually tended to happen, especially in provinces more distant from the Italian peninsula, was that a new overlay of Roman administrators, and military bigwigs, and tax collectors set up shop, some towns, mansions, and walled estates were built for the Latin-speaking gentility, and all the while, the indigenous populace of any given region continued speaking their native language and doing what they’d been doing all along. This was the case with Roman Britannia. During Saint Patrick’s youth, three hundred and fifty years after British fighting forces were subdued by Romans, Celtic Briton commoners continued to speak their native languages. While there were advantages to speaking Latin in the Roman provinces, Roman administrations hardly ever attempted the cultural homogenization of conquered subjects. As a result, wherever exactly Patrick lived, he would have spoken a language that linguists call Common Brittonic, the lingua franca of the area of the empire that could get you by throughout much of Britain. Patrick also knew Latin, although Latin was a second language for him, and one used for ecclesiastical and formal occasions. He wrote in his Confession, “I write Latin as if it were a foreign language – any reader can easily see what kind of education I had.”4 For reasons we’ll soon learn, his education was interrupted, and never resumed.
Young Patrick’s world, however, was not merely a bilingual one of Latin and Common Brittonic. Any time we’re dealing with the Roman empire, we’re dealing with a gigantic entity in which slaves are being shipped all over the place. Patrick, who lived upon the northern fringe of the Celtic Sea, and more generally, the Roman Atlantic, might have heard all sorts of languages and dialects from domestic and agricultural slaves in and around his villa. One of these languages would have been Irish. Both free and enslaved speakers of Irish lived and worked on the British west coast by the time of the Visigothic sack of Rome in 410. Some of these would have been slaves taken during skirmishes between Romans and Irish pirates and coastal towns during the previous generation or two. Others would have been Irish mercenaries and their families, welcomed into Roman Britain by provincial officials whom they had served. Generally speaking, though Ireland had never been conquered by Rome, by the time Patrick was a child, there was a lot of Roman influence in Ireland, whose ports benefited from trade with the Roman Atlantic. Roman Britain and Late Antique Ireland were separated by a tricky swathe of saltwater, but trade and migration patterns between the two islands would have made young Patrick familiar with the land the Romans called Hibernia, along with its inhabitants and their language.
So this should all give you an idea of the early life of Saint Patrick. Though he lived in a remote fringe of the Roman empire, he was an normal Roman person by the standards of the early 400s – Christian, knowing a bit of Latin but more comfortable in the region’s vernacular tongue, and tied into an economy that had since time immemorial been based on agriculture and slave labor. There are just two other things we need to know about Saint Patrick’s youth before we move on to the main events of his life. The first is that, according to his own accounts, he was far from being a faultless Christian as a young man. Patrick attributes many of the difficulties he faced later in life to a lack of genuine conviction as a youth, singling out a mysterious transgression he committed around the age of fifteen. As to what exactly the young man did, no one is certain, but in later years, once Patrick was in the clergy, the news of this youthful misdeed caused him significant trouble in his career.
Patrick, in hindsight, saw his teenage years marred by a significant infraction, and later in life, he regretted not being a more faithful Christian. But as Saint Patrick crested the hill of his teenage years and grew a little older, something far larger than a single youth’s wavering faith was rocking the western shore of Britannia. To come full circle to what we’ve already discussed, around 407, the Roman military forces stationed in Britannia packed up their things and followed the usurper emperor Constantine III across the channel, leaving Roman Britain bereft of an imperial defense force. This military departure included Roman naval powers stationed in the Irish Sea, which normally served as a buffer against Irish pirates raiding Roman Brittania’s west. Worryingly, then, after 407, the coast guard was gone. Inland, the inertia of 350 years of a Roman presence held strong for a time, even without the professional military in place. Constables and private security forces could help hold the Roman social fabric together. Out on the coasts, however, as the 400s stretched into the 410s and 420s, pirates took advantage of Britain’s unpatrolled shores. Their most famous victim was Saint Patrick himself. [music]
The Abduction and Slavery of Saint Patrick
Saint Patrick’s Confession tells the story of his abduction by Irish pirates very concisely. He writes, in the Philip Freeman translation,I was captured when I was just short of my sixteenth birthday, at a time when I had no real knowledge of God. I was led away as a slave to Ireland as were so many thousands of others. We deserved slavery – for we had abandoned God and did not follow his ways. We ignored the warnings of our priests, who pleaded with us again and again to be mindful of our eternal souls. So God poured out his anger on us and scattered us among the hordes of barbarians who live at the edge of the world.5
As is so often the case in Christian theology, Patrick blames his misfortunes not on the cruel caprices of an unfair cosmos, as a contemporary pagan would have, but instead, the displeasure of God. Though this passage toward the opening of Patrick’s Confession is thus a bit self-centered, it’s also, of course, deeply tragic – the terse tale of a teenager stolen away from his home before he even had a chance to mature.
The rugged coast of Achill Island in County Mayo. The county is often theorized as the place where Saint Patrick was enslaved, though no one knows the location for certain.
A chronicler contemporary to Saint Patrick wrote that in the year 430, the Pope Celestine sent “the Irish believing in Christ” a churchman named Palladius to be their “first bishop.”8 This little morsel of historical information is an important one. Saint Patrick has traditionally been understood as a patron saint of Ireland, and the man who brought Christianity to the Irish. Our species is overly fond of origin stories in which one lone hero cracks his knuckles and singlehandedly invents or accomplishes something. It’s just that Saint Patrick’s own Confession immediately teaches us that the Irish brought Saint Patrick to Ireland, and contemporary church history demonstrates that there were already enough Christians there for word of them to have reached the desk of the Pope in Rome, who deployed a bishop to Ireland in 431.9 Patrick, then, contrary to the exaggerations of later hagiographies, was not a single agent of Christianity in a benighted land. Ireland, by the time he first landed there, already had Christians, and the 16-year-old Patrick, upon arrival, according to his own Confession was only barely Christian himself.
The poor young man’s faith awakened once he was enslaved. In an appealing passage, he recollects in the Freeman translation that,
After I came to Ireland I watched over sheep. Day by day I began to pray more frequently – and more and more my love of God and my faith in him began to increase. My spirit was growing, so that each day I would say a hundred prayers and almost as many each night, even during those times when I had to stay overnight in the woods or mountains. I would get up each morning before sunrise to pray, through snow and frost and rain. No harm came to me because of it, and I was certainly not lazy. I see now looking back that my spirit was bursting inside me. (180)
Homesick, broken hearted, and in bondage, Patrick found solace in prayer, and for the rest of his life, he would no longer be a perfunctory Christian, but instead, a believer with considerable convictions. While later biographies of him take all sorts of poetic license in regard to his early time in Ireland, Patrick’s own words in his Confession, as plain and sparse as they are, pretty clearly explain what he went through.
Patrick tells us that while enslaved as a sheepherder, “God used the time to shape and mold me into something better. He made me into what I am now. . .someone who can care about others and work to help them” (29). With all the privileges of Patrick’s patrician boyhood stripped away, living in what may have felt like an earlier, simpler civilization based herding cattle and sheep and slowly picking up the Irish language, Patrick grew into a far more spiritual person than he’d been over in Britain. And as unenviable as Patrick’s years of bondage were, they were, all the same, important to what he’d do.
Now, if Patrick’s Confession were a saint’s life, and not an actual historical document, following some short period of slavery and a conversion narrative, Patrick would suddenly win his master over with the righteousness of Christianity, and then the local peasantry and gentry would join his flock, and straight away, Ireland would quickly repent from its pagan ways and throw itself at the foot of the cross, and faith in Jesus would splatter everywhere from the superhero powers of one exceptional believer. However, Patrick’s Confession, being rooted in actual history, is not so neat and tidy as this. Patrick, fortunately, considering his talents and contributions to world culture, did not remain in bondage forever. Instead, Patrick escaped, fled to the east, and made it back to Britannia. [music]
Patrick’s Escape from Slavery and Journey Back to Brittania
Though we can’t be sure where, exactly, Patrick was enslaved in Ireland, he tells us that he served the same master for six years. The location most often theorized is north County Mayo, due to a forest mentioned there, or the central west coast of the island, but the evidence is thin for any spot in particular.10 At the end of this period of bondage, Patrick had a providential dream telling him that his ship was ready to take him home, but, Patrick says in his Confession, “The port wasn’t nearby at all, maybe [185] miles away” (180). Accordingly, we can be confident that Patrick was enslaved within 185 miles of a port, which, when we’re talking about Ireland, does not narrow things down in any way. He later mentions hearing the voices of “those Irish who live near. . .the Western Sea” (183), likely indicating that he was enslaved near Ireland’s Atlantic coast, so there’s some solid evidence that he was in bondage over on the west side of the island. In any case, after multiple dreams telling him to return to Britain, and surely after some trepidation and agonized soul searching, Patrick began his journey. Overland travel in the ancient world was always onerous, and in Patrick’s case, if he indeed trekked 185 miles as an escaped slave, with a Brittonic accent, through the island’s interiors, through bogs, woods, hills, and all manner of private property to get to one of Ireland’s eastern ports, it must have been a hell of a terrifying journey.Eventually, he reached whatever port he’d been dreaming about. Patrick saw a ship that looked like it was bound to the east. He asked if he could join the crew as a laborer. Initially, the captain told him to get lost. But then, in a sequence of events that sounds very strange to modern ears, some of the ship’s crew invited him aboard after all. As Patrick tells it, after the ship’s captain initially rejected Patrick’s request to join the crew,
I heard one of the sailors coming up behind me and shouting: ‘Come back quickly, we want to talk with you.’ So I turned around and went back. The sailors then said to me: ‘Come on, we’ll be glad to have you aboard – make a pact of friendship with us however you’d like.’ But I refused the pagan custom of sucking on their breasts because I feared God. Still. . .I climbed up on the ship, and immediately we set out to sea. (181)
Now, for the record, there are records in antiquity of men sucking each other’s breasts to seal bonds of agreement.11 Patrick doesn’t pause to give any explanation of the strange sounding ritual, so he seems to think that we’ll be familiar with it. All told, that little excerpt of the Confession is still memorably weird. The captain tells him to take a hike. Then the sailors invite him on board, and suggest that he suck their breasts by way of sealing the deal. Patrick refuses, and yet off they go anyway.
Then, in fact, the narrative continues to be perplexing. Patrick tells us that crossing from Ireland to Britain took three days. Subsequently, after he disembarked on the island of Britain with his ship’s crew, Patrick and company stuck together, “and for twenty-eight days after that we wandered through empty country” (181). This is a bit hard to understand. A ship captain crossing the Irish sea to Britannia would have known how to navigate, even if no one had sucked his breasts prior to setting out on the voyage. The western shore of Britannia, while it wasn’t studded with metropolises, was sufficiently populated in the early fifth century that it would have been awfully hard to wander there for an entire month without running into anybody.
To stick with Patrick’s original text, though, rather than critiquing it, Saint Patrick tells us that after the ship’s crew was famished and crabby from their monthlong wandering, the ship’s captain asked if Patrick could do anything to help. A straight up miracle story follows. The captain expressed dubiety toward Patrick’s god. Patrick prayed, and suddenly a herd of pigs appeared nearby – enough to feed all of the sailors, along with the dogs that accompanied them – perhaps large Irish wolfhounds bound to be traded with Roman markets. This extraordinary occurrence, Patrick says, changed how the mariners looked at him.
Then, something equally supernatural took place. Patrick informs us that “That same night as I lay sleeping, I was attacked by Satan” (181). Specifically, says Patrick, the devil descended on Patrick, and he couldn’t move any of his limbs. In desperation, he called to the prophet Elijah for assistance, and then the great weight of Satan’s presence went away, and he was safe again. Patrick adds that he hoped that when his day of judgment came, he would also be freed from darkness by the power of prayer.
After the miracle with the pigs, and Patrick’s struggle with the devil, Patrick and his crew of mariners wandered for another ten days, until they finally found some people. These people, presumably, gave them some directions and some provisions to guide them on their way to wherever they were headed, and at some point, Patrick parted company with the seamen, because, as he tells us in the next section of the Confession, “after many years, I finally returned to my family in Britain” (182). [music]
Saint Patrick’s Career and the Fifth Century Church
Saint Patrick is very terse in his Confession in regard to his return home. His exact words are, “So after many years, I finally returned. . .to my family in Britain. They took me in – their long-lost son – and begged me earnestly that after all I had been through I would never leave them again” (182). That’s the last we hear of Patrick’s homecoming. Granted, the Confession is a spiritual autobiography mainly outlining the dramatic circumstances that led to his ministry in Ireland, but even so, he is awfully sparse in narrating his return to his family.After the terrible trauma of six years abroad in slavery, Patrick would have been a rather different person than the entitled teenager who had been kidnapped. And the world that he returned to, although it had only been six years, also would have changed. The imperial military was now gone. The moneyed classes of Brittania that had remained there had to pay for their own defense forces, and the province was quickly atomizing into towns and regions that paid private military forces directly for defense. Some of these mercenaries were of Roman stock. Others were soldiers of fortune – mercenaries with Germanic roots in some regions of Britannia, and Irish roots in others.
This mixture of homegrown Romano-British troops with Germanic and Irish fighters gave Roman Britain a stay of execution. The Romans had been there for a while, and churches buttressed their social order, too. But when Patrick returned to Britain in, say, the 420s or 430s, the lights were starting to go out. Pirates had kidnapped him, and in the remoter parts of Roman Britannia, Picts, Saxons, Irish, and others continued to test the waters of a Roman province no longer protected by the full might of Rome, sometimes raiding, sometimes settling, and everything in between. Barbarian mercenaries protected Romano-British towns and estates, right up until the time when it became more advantageous to join their confederates in sacking those towns and estates.
To sum up, when Patrick returned from Ireland, the Roman gentry of Britain was living on borrowed time. Additionally, it wasn’t long before Patrick decided that he no longer wanted to live among the well-heeled Romans of a fading province. Some time after his homecoming, Patrick began to have visions. He dreamt of receiving letters, one of which called Patrick a “holy boy,” (183), and begged him to come back to Ireland’s western shore. Later, he heard a prayer in his sleep, and later still, he had a vision of someone else praying from within him.
Giambattista Tiepolo’s Saint Patrick, Bishop of Ireland (1746) shows the bishop healing a sick man. Most biographies and artwork dealing with Saint Patrick over the past 1500 years have ignored his life and career and hurried toward the miracle stories.
By the early 400s, the typical aspiring churchman’s path went from laity, and then upward to deacon, and then priest, and from there, for some, a further and much more significant ascension to the rank of bishop. As mentioned earlier, being an aristocrat, or being born into the clergy, were strong advantages to ascending the ladder of the ecclesiastical hierarchy. The Catholic church’s embrace of clerical celibacy was only gradually spreading by the life of Saint Patrick, and so a priest could have a son who became a priest, with some Roman ecclesiastical offices essentially being hereditary, barring any significant misconduct. Thus, due to both his religious awakening over in Ireland as well as being born into a family of churchmen, a career path in the church made perfect sense for the young man when he returned. The question was not, perhaps, whether or not Patrick would join the clergy, but which echelon of the clergy he would aspire to.
Though Patrick doesn’t mention it in his Confession, he might have studied abroad, specifically in Gaul or just off its southern coast, as some later sources attest. However, according to his own account, his Latin was poor and his education had been interrupted by slavery, and so it’s also likely that he used paternal connections in Britain to become ordained.12 The ordination wouldn’t have been simply given to him, though. Beginning as a deacon in his twenties, Patrick would have had to make himself useful performing errands and repetitious work for priests and bishops, and the young man, who had served as a slave and ministered to the needs of an actual flock, surely had plenty of experience multitasking and getting his hands dirty with hard work. Though there were exceptions in the early church, a priest was supposed to be at least thirty years old prior to ordination, and a bishop, fifty.
Patrick is famous for being a bishop in Ireland, but based on the primary sources, we don’t know whether he stayed in Britannia for some thirty years, becoming a deacon, and then priest, and then bishop, all before going to minister in Ireland, or whether he went to Ireland decades earlier, in order to spread the faith there as a priest. It is odd that he doesn’t include a single word about the nuts and bolts of his ecclesiastical career prior to being a bishop associated with an Irish ministry, as late antique churchmen placed stock in who studied with whom. In Patrick’s case, he might have undergone some of his clerical training with the bishop of one of the large British dioceses – Londinium, Lindum Colonia, or Lincoln, or Eboracum, or York. It is probable that he went to Ireland sooner, rather than later. A knowledge of the language, the prophetic dreams he had, and the hunger of youthful ambitions would have led the clerical establishment and his own wishes to send him over at the beginning of his career, rather than toward the end. Assuming that he became a priest, went to Ireland in his thirties and distinguished himself there for the next two decades, he would have been ordained as a bishop once into his middle age, and expected to continue his ministry over in Ireland. The only clue he offers in his Confession is that when he was declared a bishop, “I wasn’t in Britain at the time nor was it my idea” (185), which likely indicates that he had distinguished himself sufficiently as a leader in Ireland that his peers saw his bishopric there as a foregone conclusion.
So, to recapitulate, Patrick himself doesn’t explain his career much. Instead, in one paragraph, he says he came home from Ireland at about the age of 21, and that his family welcomed him. Then, we hear that he had some strange dreams and visions involving Ireland. And then, there’s a flashforward, and suddenly he’s talking about how, when he was a bishop, he himself was the subject of a church scandal. Let’s discuss that scandal. [music]
The Mysterious Transgression of Patrick’s Youth
The reason Patrick wrote his Confession was not out of any sense that his life was so important that posterity needed to know about it. The document is actually intended for a specific contemporary audience – other churchmen who doubted Patrick’s merits due to a controversy in which he was embroiled. It happens to contain a lot of information about his life. But in its own time, it was written as a sort of CV for the dubious, and a self-portrait that emphasized who Patrick actually was, and what he’d actually done with his life and work.
An enthuiast dressed as the bishop in the 2014 Saint Patrick’s Day Parade in Dublin. Though plenty of apocryphal stories about him are still alive and well, Patrick’s overall legacy and positive impact on early medieval Irish history are still revered today. Photo by Miguel Mendez.
While Patrick makes clear that the church scandal was distressing to him, he also makes clear that he had already regretted his youthful mistake, and that not long after it, he’d been kidnapped and enslaved in Ireland as, at least in part, punishment by God for his lack of faith. Patrick also records hearing a voice telling him that God was angry that the bishop Patrick was the subject of a church scandal – specifically, Patrick heard the words, “We are very angry that my chosen one has been criticized” (184), and thus, though the nasty secret about his youth had gone out and he had been shamed and felt betrayed as a result, Patrick also felt like God had forgiven him and that he had paid his penance for being a crappy Christian in his early years.
We are about halfway through Patrick’s Confession, and just on the verge of the period of his actual bishopric in Ireland, and I want to pause for a moment just to review a couple of things we’ve learned so far. Patrick can be extremely humble in his Confession, and less often, he can be pretty puffed up. He tells us in the document’s opening sentences that he’s just a sinner and schmuck like anyone else, and really, worse than everyone else. Later, he says his Latin is bad, tells us that he was afraid and weak, and admits that as a bishop he suffered from a pretty damaging scandal. At other junctures, as when he recalls hearing God call him “my chosen one,” Patrick clearly feels like he is a Christian of some esteem on whom God has placed the burden of a very important ministry.
These fluctuations likely reveal the real personality of Ireland’s most famous bishop, a man who knew his own flaws, but who also felt like after a harrowing youth, he’d gone back to the land of his captivity to try and make it a better place. The Confession, as I mentioned, is only about twenty pages long and it’s absolutely worth reading for yourself. Within the many letters and tomes that fourth and fifth century Christianity, left behind, it stands out as especially poignant and lucid. Patrick’s prose is pretty simple. Patrick’s older contemporaries, most famously Jerome and Augustine, were marvelous Latin stylists, but this leads them often to grandstanding and showing off, and looking at Patrick’s simpler prose alongside contemporary polemical tracts against various heresies, it’s hard not to feel like Patrick genuinely just wanted to bring Christianity and the welfare of the Christian church to as many people as he could, rather than showboating and politicking and sparring with theological rivals.
This simplicity is a huge part of the appeal of what Patrick left behind. If Jerome or Augustine had been vocationally threatened by a rival, either would have aimed a firehose of vitriol against their opponents, leveling accusations of heresy against perceived threats and dashing out multivolume tracts for all posterity. In contrast, and very appealingly, in my opinion, Patrick says he did some stupid stuff during his youth, one of his friends brought it up, that friend hurt his feelings and Patrick felt ashamed of himself, but by that point he was a bishop with work to do, and so he went on with his life and career. Turning the other cheek then, in large part because he was a busy person in a fresh new diocese with a lot on the line, Patrick ultimately comes across as a more human and inspiring person than some of his more intellectually feisty predecessors. In fact, let’s talk about those predecessors for just a moment. [music]
Pelagianism and Fifth Century Britain
The fourth century was not only a time of struggle between Romans and outsiders. It was also an absolutely critical time for the development of Christianity. What we now understand as Christianity emerged during the 300s, out of a welter of earlier, much more diverse Chrisitan movements. A key set of theologians, most importantly Saint Ambrose, and then Saints Jerome and Augustine, pushed for a severer, more ascetic, celibate clergy, and generally, a graver and more self-denying version of Christianity. These theologians were born in the mid-300s, and thus a generation or two prior to Saint Patrick. Those who disagreed with them were branded as heretics and excommunicated, although in hindsight, theologians like Jovinian and Pelagius, victims of late Roman Christianity’s culture wars, seem pretty reasonable by modern standards. At the top of Saint Jerome’s ideological hit list was the theologian Jovinian, who dared to opine that all Christians were equal in heaven, that ascetic, celibate monks didn’t get any special rewards in the afterlife, and that Mary, as the New Testament pretty clearly indicates, was not a virgin all her life, in spite of Saint Jerome’s sentiments otherwise. Jerome savaged Jovinian as a gross hedonist, though, and that has generally been how Christian posterity has remembered him.
A stained glass portrait of Pope Celestine I in Saint Patrick’s Cathedral in Dundalk, County Louth. The pope was playing power politics with his selection of bishops in Britain and Ireland during the early 400s so as to combat Pelagianism in the region. Photo by Andreas F. Borchert.
As with so much theological history, temperatures were hot on the subject of Pelagian free will because careers and reputations were involved. If you give believers the keys to their own salvation via Pelagian free will, then the importance of the church and the clergy is suddenly jeopardized. Original sin, by contrast, makes the fate of the individual believer an ongoing crisis, and one that requires ecclesiastical intervention at recurring intervals. History proved to be on the side of Augustine, whose connections were as powerful as his pen was vicious, and the Romano-British churchman Pelagius, whoever exactly he was, was excommunicated and lived out the remainder of his life in Egypt. Considering that Pelagius believed that pious Christians could simply do good on their own via the exercise of reason and free will, this excommunication may not have weighed terribly heavily on him.
Let’s turn back toward the subject of Saint Patrick, now. The bishop who served Ireland before Saint Patrick was called Palladius. Palladius had been involved with Britain before he became the first bishop of Ireland. In the year 429, Palladius had accompanied another bishop to Roman Britain to combat the teachings of Pelagius, which were evidently popular there. The Pope seems to have been pleased at the results of this mission to combat the nasty and evil ideas of free will and self-determination, and, seeing Palladius’ performance in the field, a couple of years later, in 431, the Pope dispatched Palladius as the first bishop of Ireland.
This dispatch, as I said earlier, indicates that in 431 there were enough Christians in Ireland to merit a bishop there. But the pope’s decision to send Palladius up to the far northwest may have also been related to the theological controversy still smoldering in Britain. Palladius had shown he could combat the Pelagian heresy. Perhaps Pope Celestine sent the bishop there when he did precisely because he wanted to make Ireland a bulwark against Pelagian Christianity that was still fashionable in Britain.13 In general, by the time Ireland welcomed its first bishop in 431, there were enough Christians there to necessitate one – Popes didn’t deploy bishops to minister to empty pews, because that doesn’t make sense. And in general, Ireland likely would have welcomed a bishop at some point in the 400s or 500s, no matter what, because Christianity was spreading organically through evangelical operations not necessarily steered by the papacy. But it is also fairly likely that in 431, the bishop Palladius was deployed to fend off any Romano-British attempt to seat a Pelagian bishop there, and thus that the Christianization of Ireland was significantly impacted by Late Antique culture wars in the church.
Palladius is relevant to Saint Patrick first, because Palladius was Saint Patrick’s predecessor. Second, it’s interesting to consider the complexity of the world Saint Patrick entered as he climbed the ranks of the church, where you were often one doctrinal error away from heresy and excommunication. And third, Saint Patrick may have served Palladius in some capacity as a priest or deacon, possibly sopping up anti-Pelagian ideas from his boss in the process. Whatever relationship Saint Patrick had with Palladius, including none at all, Patrick would have been aware of his predecessor’s career and background prior to becoming bishop of Ireland himself.
So as you can see, although we have some circumstantial understanding of the middle part of Saint Patrick’s career, just based on what was normal for the career path of a Christian churchman and what was going on during this crucial phase of the church’s history, there’s a lot that we’re missing, too. Whatever Patrick’s precise career trajectory was, and however it happened, at some point around, say, 450 or 460, as the western Roman empire fell into deeper and deeper twilight, the man who had first learned the Irish language as a slave returned to teach the Irish about Christianity. [music]
A Bishop’s Role in a Pagan Territory
Patrick wound up in the northern part of Ireland. His Confession is never specific about where he set up shop, and like a lot of bishops where intensive missionary and public service work was being carried out, Patrick would have traveled where he was needed. In his own writings, Patrick is also never explicit about the people to whom he ministered – we don’t know how many Christians there were during his career in Ireland, nor who, precisely they were.Many of them would have been Romano-British slaves. Shipped over from Britain like Patrick himself had been years earlier, some of these slaves were allowed access to Christian worship rites by their masters. Sometimes, a slave’s charisma and piety could lead to the conversion of a master. Additionally, while the information we have on the subject is hagiographic and from long after the 400s, there were likely some missionaries at work before the time of Patrick.
Though Millet’s Man with a Hoe (c. 1862) was a painting of a different peasantry, Patrick’s congregants would have largely been the laborers and slaves of Late Antique Ireland, pausing from their work to listen to the bishop as he passed by their fields.
Early clergymen, especially if they were in a strange land like Ireland, would have had to wear a lot of hats. The urban bishops of, for instance, Merovingian France a century later were effectively the governors of small city-states, in addition to the ministers of congregations. Patrick’s flock would have been smaller than the urban bishoprics of Merovingian Francia or contemporary Britain, but all the same, his job would have been taxing. While Patrick would have had subordinates, his famous career in Ireland surely involved some adventures and ups and downs – problems with locals, issues with internal human resources, a dearth of food here, a shortage of beds there, an angry master looking for a escaped slave here, a pugnacious polytheistic lord there, and on and on. Patrick, though was following in the footsteps of other missionaries, was extemporizing an entire new organization and ideology in a landscape charged with the awesome legacy of pagan Irish religion, and the fact that he was successful is a testament to his energy, brainpower, and his intuition with people.
Irish civilization, in the 400s, was comparable to that which existed in pre-Islamic Arabia during the same period. Just as Arabs had the qabiila, or tribe, as a basic social unit, the Irish had the túath. A rural civilization anchored in animal husbandry, and particularly cattle, Ireland during the 400s was not ruled by kings in stone castles, but instead chiefs of grazing territories circumscribed by natural topography and established intertribal borders. It was, like all Late Antique societies spared the dubious benefits of imperial colonization, a complex place, with its own literary and artistic culture, politics, and regional norms. There were laws and tacit rules, and breaking them had consequences. When Patrick had escaped slavery as a young man and ran scared across much of the island, he had surely trespassed and skulked his way through numerous fiefdoms where trespassing was a crime. As a bishop, he was no longer just one stranger in a strange land, but instead a leader with many others accountable to his mistakes. Patrick thus had to play his hand extremely carefully, respecting not only the boundaries of tribal lands, but also the norms of Ireland’s social hierarchy and the behavior expected of foreigners there.
Later biographies of Patrick from the medieval period imagine him momentously meeting a mysterious high king of Ireland and then overawing this monarch with miracles. There was, however, in the mid-400s, almost certainly no overlord of all Ireland whom Patrick could have impressed with magic tricks. Instead, as his Confession makes quite clear, Patrick navigated the intricacies of Irish tribal politics, using every tool at his disposal to get safe passage around the island and preach everywhere he was permitted to do so.
One of the main tools he used to get around was paying for safe passage through tribal territories. He writes in his Confession,
I spent money to bribe the local kings to receive me. For your sake, Irish Christians, I traveled everywhere among great dangers. I even went to the most remote parts of the island – places at the very edge of the world. .I paid out this money to those in power in those regions I have visited frequently. . .I’m not sorry that I paid out bribes – in fact, I’m not finished yet. I spend money now and will spend even more. By the power of God, I may even spend my own life for your souls. (191)
While later saint’s lives imagine Patrick momentously arriving in king’s courts and stunning them with stock miracles, what he actually did was both messier and more impressive. Patrick tells us that his whole mission in Ireland was criticized by outsiders. He makes clear that his life in Ireland was pretty barebones, writing elsewhere, “Money? Even if I wanted to be rich, there’s not much chance of that, believe me. On the contrary, every day I keep expecting to be murdered, assaulted, sold back into slavery, or some such thing” (192). Living a spartan existence by necessity, then, Patrick used much of the new diocese’s resources as essentially protection money, handing it out to powerful chiefs and their superintendents, but even then, being perpetually one betrayal or misunderstanding away from death.
It is important to remember that Late Antique Ireland wasn’t somehow removed from the goings on of Britain and the continent. Irish people had been trading with Romans for centuries, and before them the Greeks, and the Celtic Sea had its own systems of commerce. Additionally, as early Irish literature suggests, and scholarship on early Irish law suggests, traditional Irish society had a logical superstructure designed to offer basic guarantees of safety and fairness to the common citizen and the passage of goods through various kingdoms in a way that was broadly sustainable and useful to life on the island. Nonetheless, Patrick was no mere foreign trader. As diplomatic as he must have been, and as inoffensive as Christianity’s doctrines were, his presence as a proselytizer made him an acute disturbance to the status quo, and little about his ministry could have been easy.
Patrick’s base of operations was likely in the northeast of the island, where regular trade with Britain facilitated the year-round presence of a diverse population of merchants and middlemen who already had agreements with local leadership. This merchant settlement, already a hodgepodge of British, Irish, Romans, and others, would have made a logical beachhead for Christian missionary work to the south and west. Heading deeper into Ireland throughout his career as a bishop, Patrick dispersed money to guarantee safe passage and secure the tolerance of otherwise prickly local leadership. And among the various kings and princes who probably scoffed at the strange British monotheist who had come to convert them, there was a class of people who have not yet been mentioned in this program – a select set of sages and spiritual leaders among the Irish, most often known to us today as druids. [music]
Druids and Bards in Late Antique Ireland: Fiction and Fact
Saint Patrick preached Christianity in a land where what we can most simply call “Irish paganism” was the norm. There are many sources on traditional Celtic religion, from the ancient Greek historian Posidonius around 80 BCE all the way to Medieval Christian chroniclers of various stamps who lived in western Europe and were curious about the Celtic past. Modern archaeology has added a lot to our knowledge of traditional Celtic religion, but the fact is that Celtic religion, like ancient Greek religion, endured for more than a thousand years, had many different permutations, varied immensely in different times and places, and is difficult to generalize about. Thus, put very simply, the Irish speaking population among whom Patrick sought to spread the Gospels practiced a polytheistic religion rooted in very old Celtic narratives, some of them would have revered traditional Irish gods and goddesses, and they would have also had cult practices and sacred story cycles endemic to the culture of various corners of Ireland over the course of the 400s CE.Traditional Celtic religion is a gigantic subject with all of the usual historiographical problems we encounter when we try to learn about a polytheistic religion chronicled by monotheists in later centuries. There are various reports by Greeks and Romans, and then later by Christian historians, that Celts were a wild bunch, sometimes miscreants and sometimes noble savages, and stories survive about human sacrifices and various other heathen rites out of step with classical and Christian norms, as we heard earlier. Of all of the various things written about druids during antiquity and the Middle Ages, one of the earliest is a good place to start in order to understand the fact and fiction around druids. Julius Caesar’s Gallic Wars, written during the 50s BCE, records his impressions of druids in Gaul. Here are a few observations that Caesar makes about druids:
Druids. . .are engaged in things sacred, conduct the public and the private sacrifices, and interpret all matters of religion. To [druids] a large number of the young men resort for the purposes of instruction, and [the druids] are in great honor among them. For they determine respecting almost all controversies, public and private, and if any crime has been perpetrated, if murder has been committed, if there be any dispute about an inheritance, if any boundaries, these same persons decide it. . .The Druids do not go to war, nor pay tribute together with the rest; they have an exemption from military service and a dispensation in all matters. Induced by such great advantages, many embrace this profession of their own accord, and [many] are sent to it by their parents and relations. They are said. . .to learn a great number of verses; accordingly some remain in the course of training twenty years.14These observations are not too far off from what Irish law tracts written seven hundred years later tell us about the training and careers of Irish bards during the early Middle Ages. Barbarian societies of pre-Christian Europe broadly had an educated class of functionaries who served as spiritual leaders and the arbitrators of disputes – we might generally call them “wise men.” In Celtic societies, these functionaries seemed to have had extensive training and to sometimes have inherited their vocations through patrilineage, carrying oral history and story cycles down through the ages, as well as performing the animal sacrifices normal to premodern civilizations. What we just heard Caesar tell us there about the druids of Gaul around 50 BCE doesn’t sound very sensational. He says the druids were educated people who filled legal and ceremonial roles and were respected by their parent societies.
Patrick preaches in an illustration from the first half of the fourteenth century. Sensational stories about Patrick fighting druids proliferated in later centuries, but on the ground in the 400s CE, Patrick and his intellectual counterparts in Late Antique Ireland would have had enough commonalities to smooth over many of their differences.
Let’s turn toward the facts about druids, insofar as they’re available to us. Seven hundred years after Caesar lived, surviving Irish law tracts were set down that lay out the responsibilities of the fili, which means “seer,” and also, “poet,” a figure who sounds basically like an educated officeholder whose main responsibilities are public entertainment and legal arbitration. Imagine a lawyer who is also great on a microphone and knows a lot of stories and can MC a funeral in a way that’s respectful to various gods, and you have a druid or bard. Later Christians – including those who wrote the four great cycles of medieval Irish literature – like Caesar did, enjoyed telling tall tales about druids, because these tall tales are a lot of fun. From medieval Irish language works like the Book of Invasions and the “First Battle of Mag Tuired,” it seems like every village had a druid casting spells, making fire rain down during battles, and changing into birds. Real druids, however, were more boring than this, being civil servants employed by various petty kings, who as much as anything else, were essentially responsible for the preservation of tradition and the maintenance of social order.
Let’s return to the story of Saint Patrick. Later hagiography imagines Patrick battling druids, and we’ll look one such scene toward the end of this program. Abrahamic religion has always loved wizard battles in which Abrahamic religion wins, from the tale of Moses in the court of the Pharaoh onward. But miracle stories aside, it is interesting to speculate about the actual long-lost history of how Christianity successfully trickled into the polytheistic ranks of Ireland in the 400s and 500s.
Patrick would have been vulnerable to any power blocs led by pagan reactionaries that directed themselves against Christian ministry on the island. From the sound of his Confession, he spent a lot of time trekking around and tipping people five dollars here and there to allow him to preach next to a chicken coop or donkey cart. In spite of such humble beginnings, eventually, at least where Patrick had established a foothold for Irish Christianity somewhere in the northeast, he had converted a lot of people. His success, to some extent, speaks to the tolerance and porousness of Celtic polytheism, and the druids and bards that preserved its sagas and ceremonies. Lacking codified doctrines and a monolithic clergy, bearers of native Irish traditions would have seen Patrick as an oddball and outlander, rather than a heretic. Rome had been Christian for at least a century by the time Patrick began evangelizing there, and among the educated keepers of Irish lore, around 450, the basics of Christianity were probably often familiar.
When the real Patrick met real druids, then, he was an educated professional speaking with other educated professionals. As druids and bards were also public servants, who also performed, and were also concerned with the order and welfare of their small kingdoms, Patrick and his pagan Irish counterparts may not have been so locked into mortal combat as later saint’s lives imagined. In fact, let’s discuss the kinds of things that Patrick would have done during his evangelical work – things that could have hardly been objectionable to the odd druid or bard who happened to pass by while Patrick was at work. [music]
Saint Patrick and Christian Humanitarian Aid
As we’ve learned in previous seasons of Literature and History, Christianity succeeded for numerous reasons, all of them easy to understand. First, and most importantly, unlike other salvific cult religions during the Roman imperial period, Christianity explicitly had worldwide proselytization as its goal, and it succeeded because it wanted to succeed. Comparable salvation-based cult religions, centered on various saviors and mother-son pairings, like Isis and Horus, or Cybele and Attis, were often based on esoteric rituals and secret membership rites. In the 100s and 200s, you could attend the sacred rituals of Dionysus Zagreus, or the empowering ceremonies of Mithras, but these were members-only events. Christianity also had appealing sacraments for participants, as well as sacred narrative cycles, but wherever it was safe to do so, they were shared with potential converts.In the case of Christianity disembarking in ancient Ireland in the 300s and 400s, an organized ecclesiastical institution bent on ideological world domination landed in a polytheistic civilization and began doing its work. Druids and faithful devotees of traditional Celtic religions, as later Irish literature demonstrates, had a legacy of story cycles and traditions centuries deep. They did not, however, have an intercontinental organization with funding and an outright goal of ideological imperialism. In summation, then, the most important reason why Christianity spread in Ireland, and other non-Roman territories, during the fifth century because it was trying to spread. We do not, after all, hear of druids preaching the gospel of Lugh in the breezeways of the Roman coliseum.
While the most important reason for Christianity’s expansion was that organized evangelism was a large part of the religion’s doctrine, there were, of course, many other reasons as well. The most significant of these was that Christianity brought a consistent infrastructure for public welfare wherever it went. In the case of Saint Patrick, his operational base in the northern part of Ireland would have served a population that included a substantial number of Christian slaves and lowborn Irish people for whom the alms of the church offered the basics of survival. If you were a vagabond, or a local hired hand; a runaway or a sailor out of work, a Christian missionary estate would give you a place to get the basic necessities of life. You could, as a catechumen or convert, also find work there.
Millet’s The Gleaners (1857). The working poor would have made up a sizable part of Patrick’s followers.
Because Christianity largely wrote the history of its own expansion, we too often get the impression that its missionary operations were bastions of enlightened generosity in a howling wilderness of pagan cruelty. The values of generosity toward the poor and helpless were widespread in ancient pagan societies. What Christianity got right was not the invention of charity to the poor, but the operational consistency of charity to the poor. It showed up with seed money to pay for basic guarantees of safety, acquired a modest amount of property in the form of a farm or two, offered alms to the needy, and from motley, modest beginnings, grew indigenous clergy driven to further proselytize among their own.
We’ve just talked about how Christianity expanded because expansion was sort of the whole point, and how Christian missionary undertakings like Saint Patrick’s succeeded through consistent charitable outreach. A third reason for Christianity’s success is a bit less widely understood, and that was its appeal to women. Saint Patrick’s Confession, written decades into his missionary work, records how women numbered high among the early Christian converts of Ireland. Patrick tells us,
You can see that the sons and daughters of Irish kings have become brothers and virgins for Christ. . .But many of them do this against the wishes of their parents. Indeed, their families sometimes punish them cruelly and make all sorts of horrible accusations against them. Still, the number of such virgins who have chosen this new life continues to grow so that I can’t keep track of them all. This doesn’t even include widows and married women who abstain from sex. Sadly, of such women, the ones who suffer the most are the slaves. They face rape and constant threats but suffer this abuse bravely. God gives these women the grace to follow courageously in this path even though they are forbidden to do so. (188-9)
Patrick’s assessment of the hardships of some of his congregation here is frank and plainspoken. He has no illusions that the women who converted to Christianity under his ministry were suddenly transported into happiness. He doesn’t tiptoe around the horror of being a woman in slavery. Instead, he celebrates the quantity of converts that have come his way, and applauds the self-renunciation that they have undertaken for the sake of Christianity, because it could, at least, offer community and some hope.
We should pause for just a moment here to recall a couple of things about female virginity in the mind of a fifth-century churchman like Saint Patrick. Saint Patrick’s predecessors, Saint Augustine and Saint Jerome, wrote extensively abouts sex and virginity. In Augustine’s Confessions, the paramount of the seven deadly sins with which he struggles is lust. Comparably, Jerome served as a spiritual counselor to patrician matrons and their daughters in Rome in the 380s, applauding them endlessly for embracing celibacy, and writing rather ugly generalizations about how non-celibate women were poorer Christians than virgins were. Saint Patrick, like his predecessors, was, at least to some degree, caught up in the fifth century Christian mania for female virginity.
This mania was not driven exclusively by the clergy. During antiquity, regardless of place and time, women were most often an underclass, and their lives were hard. We’ve met a lot of civilizations from the ancient world in our podcast, and although we meet an Inanna here and an Athena there, the general rule was that the connected cultures of west Eurasia and north Africa were a man’s world, hard for everyone, but harder for women. Ancient Irish society, like so many other Late Antique civilizations, had some quirks that slightly eased the trials of being born female. Divorce, for instance, was acceptable for a number of reasons. If domestic violence were part of the picture, or adultery, or slander, a woman could divorce her husband. If a man proved unable to have sex, his wife could divorce him, and in an arrangement unusual in the ancient world, if a woman were married to an impotent man, there were legal ways she could become pregnant by another man and compel her husband to raise the resulting children as his own.16 Irish mythology has its warrior queen Mebd, and various traditions survive about Celtic women fighting on the battlefield, most famously Boudica. But on the whole, Late Antique Irish society was a typical west Eurasian polytheistic civilization, and women there, though there were surely happy marriages and powerful patrician ladies, on average, had less freedom and self-determination than their male counterparts did.
Saint Patrick, like other Christian proselytizers, knew that Christianity gave women in a pagan society a new choice. For pagan women who did not want to have children, or who didn’t want to have any more children, and for pagan women otherwise poorly served by their indigenous societies, Christianity provided an offramp toward something else. To us today, the writings of fourth- and fifth-century Christian churchmen on female celibates can sound a little clunky. A pagan Irishwoman who converted to Christianity in, say, 450 CE, went from one civilization that sought to regulate her sexuality to another civilization that also wanted to regulate her sexuality. Christianity, however, also offered a commune of likeminded believers, and opportunities for a life beyond domestic labor, farm work, and child rearing. Saint Patrick, as we heard a moment ago, wrote that many of the young Irish converts who came to him did so “against the wishes of their parents,” and especially for young women pushed into arranged marriages and motherhood, Christian chastity was at least a viable alternative.
Though Patrick doesn’t dwell on them, the non-celibate would also have been a part of his missionary operation’s initial footprint in Ireland, and its continued expansion thereafter. With Christianity having won the day over Europe a thousand years ago, it’s strange for us to imagine that the religion was, to conservative pagans, understood as a countercultural, new age upset to long established traditions. Its converts, in addition to the desperate and needy, included sons and daughters and odd ducks of pagan civilization looking for something different. Some of these converts did embrace celibacy. Others, far more often, converted before or after marriage and children, bringing a subsequent generation up under the auspices of the growing cadre of monotheists on the island. [music]
Patrick and the Nightmare of Coroticus
As the 400s wore onward, Roman Britain continued to plunge into disarray. During this transitional period of British history, as was happening in other areas of the collapsing empire, a passel of strongmen, some Roman, and some barbarian, styled themselves as the warlords of short-lived fiefdoms. The historian Gildas mentions a Romano-British warlord named Ambrosius Aurelianus who fought against an Anglo-Saxon invasion. Bede mentions a certain Vortigern as the self-appointed king of the Britons – we’ll meet these folks in later episodes. As for Saint Patrick, he was unlucky enough to have a very close encounter, late in his life, with a Romano-British warband leader named Coroticus.So far in this program, we’ve only dealt with one of the two documents Saint Patrick left behind – his Confession. The second document is the “Letter to the Soldiers of Coroticus,” and it’s time for us to examine this second, albeit smaller window into fifth-century Irish history. Let’s start by learning about Coroticus himself. Coroticus was a warlord and slaver from the west coast of Britain. Taking advantage of the Roman military withdrawal from Britain a generation or so before, Coroticus led a band of raiders across the Irish Sea and attacked some of Saint Patrick’s Christian community. The attack sounds horrific. Some converts who had just been baptized had been heading home. Coroticus and his raiders had butchered most of the men, and kidnapped women and children to sell them into slavery. And then, they were gone. At some point, as an old churchman who’d been working for the main part of his career to evangelize, Saint Patrick learned that a swathe of his congregation had been killed and enslaved. Unable to do much else, Patrick wrote an open letter to Coroticus and his thugs, and copies of it were distributed not only to the warlord himself, but also to high churchmen in Britain and prominent Christians in Ireland as a means of coping with the tragedy.
The letter is palpable in its anger, but also, still composed in the restrained, dignified prose that seems to have been Patrick’s epistolary style. A salient point is that Coroticus seems to have been a Christian, or at least a Romano-British citizen raised beneath Christianity. Let’s hear some of the opening of the brokenhearted bishop’s letter, in the Philip Freeman translation:
I don’t like to use forceful words or harsh language, but I will do it because the anger of God and the truth of Christ force me to. I do it for the love of my neighbors here in Ireland and for my spiritual children. I have traded in my homeland, my family, and my very life for them – even if it means my death. If I am worthy, I will devote the rest of my days to teaching the Irish. . .
With my own hands I write this letter – given to my messenger, carried on [his] way, and handed over to you, the soldiers of Coroticus. Notice I don’t call you ‘my fellow Romans’ – no, your crimes have made you citizens of Hell!
You live like the worst barbarians, including your Pictish friends. Blood, blood, blood! Your hands drip with the blood of the innocent Christians you have murdered – the very Christians I nourished and brought to God.
My newly baptized converts, still in their white robes, the sweet smell of the anointing oil still on their foreheads – you murdered them, cut them down with your swords. (169-70)
It is clear, here, that poor Patrick was barely holding on after the loss of his congregants. As the letter continues, we learn more about what happened. Patrick writes that he dispatched a priest to intercept Coroticus and ask the warlord to return the manacled Christians, and that Coroticus laughed at the messenger. Coroticus, Patrick writes will soon be a captive himself, for a very long time, in hell.
Saint Patrick in a 1925 stained glass window. Patrick has inspired some of the finest stained glass artwork in the world, though I genuinely don’t know why he has a single blue, bedazzled glove on in this particular portrait.
The Letter to the Soldiers of Coroticus ascends to a note of piercing tragedy when Patrick dwells on what Coroticus’ attack did. Patrick imagines that even God’s own heart is broken at the loss of the new converts, even as “your work has been going so well in Ireland – countless sons and daughters of Irish kings are becoming brothers and virgins for Christ” (172). There is some consolation. The Christian congregants of his community, he says, would at least know the rewards of heaven. And Patrick ends the missive by saying he hopes Coroticus will hear the words of the letter, and try to repent and be Christians.
All told, Saint Patrick’s Letter to the Soldiers of Coroticus has the same rich, plainspoken sincerity as his Confession. Though the letter crackles with anger, showing a bishop who is raw and despairing, the letter is not a fancy rhetorical performance, designed to impress. Instead, Patrick tells Coroticus and his raiders the facts – they have murdered and kidnapped Christians. They are in trouble. There are well known Christian laws against the atrocities they’ve committed, laws so ubiquitous that they don’t even need a bunch of pedantic chapter and verse quotations to demonstrate them. Coroticus and his murderers will not be welcomed in decent society after their brutalities. It is hard enough, Patrick says, even for decent Christians to walk a righteous path. But transgressions like Coroticus’ are gruesome, and will be forgotten by neither God, nor humanity.
Again, the purpose of the letter seems genuinely to have been to get Coroticus to try and stop doing awful things to innocent people. The superintendent of an extremely vulnerable community, Patrick didn’t have time to bloviate and split theological hairs, nor to leave behind fancy exegeses that disproved the ideas of rival theologians. The bishop of a territory that was perpetually in crisis, it’s only fitting that the only text Patrick left behind other than the Confession simply seeks to make the world safe for Christianity. [music]
Did the Letter to Coroticus Impact Patrick’s Career?
There’s just one more thing about Saint Patrick that we need to learn in this episode – a final part of his story that is suspected as much as it is evident in the two documents he left behind. That final thing is to puzzle out his relationship with his colleagues in the Romano-British church over on the other side of the Irish Sea.Patrick’s 20-page Confession serves a few different purposes. It’s a very short autobiography. It’s a description of his missionary work in Ireland. But it’s also a tract of self-defense. Let’s talk about the self-defense. So far in this episode, we’ve danced around the issue of why Patrick wrote the Confession. Earlier, we learned that the document mentions a mysterious sin he committed “not even a day but in an hour” (184) decades before writing the Confession, as a young teenager. And we learned that the news of this sin had begun circulating because he’d confessed it to a close friend, who had passed the story on. But what if something else warranted Saint Patrick’s Confession – something besides an age-old indiscretion? What if Patrick had a strained relationship with the Romano-British church for different reasons?
Saint Augustine, a generation or two older than Patrick, savaged theologians whose views were different than his, ushering in a severer era of Christianity and adding dangerous doctrinal trap doors to the average clergyman’s career. Patrick came of age in a newly volatile and politicized of the early church.
Patrick, in spite of his perfectly good Romano-British pedigree, has a recurring underdog complex in his writings, and to conjecture for a moment, maybe this complex existed precisely because an influential group of Romano-British churchmen in the 400s simply didn’t think Ireland was worth God’s time. Patrick wanted to go to Ireland? these colleagues were incredulous to learn. Then let him go to Ireland, because no one else wanted to minister over there! It’s just that Patrick didn’t get himself killed, nor did he fade into obscurity. He did his work well, and Ireland’s population of Christians grew, and while Patrick’s Romano-British colleagues may have regarded him as a second-class churchman due to the ignominious reputation of the region he served, Patrick thought of himself as a Christian ministering to those in need, like any other Christian cleric. To his Romano-British colleagues, then, Saint Patrick was a motley figure – a man with a congregation full of barbarians who really shouldn’t have succeeded, but was just too damned tenacious and talented to simply fade away.
The “Letter to the Soldiers of Coroticus” was written before the Confession. As we just learned, the letter castigated Coroticus, and Patrick may have written it to see if he might secure the return of some of his kidnapped congregants. The letter was the logical action of a man in an absolutely awful situation. However, the “Letter to the Soldiers of Coroticus” seems to have been the very thing that landed Patrick in hot water with his Romano-British peers.17 The reason for this is that warlords like Coroticus were becoming fixtures in Romano-British society. They were raiders and slave traders, sure, but in Coroticus’ case, his raiding and slave trading was happening over in Ireland, and the Irish had been raiding and enslaving Roman Britain, so to the social order of Romano-Britain in, say, 450 CE, Coroticus was a warlord whose actions were morally defensible. Coroticus would have had priests and a bishop of his own, wherever he lived on the eastern shore of the Irish Sea. These priests and bishop, once they received a copy of Patrick’s Letter to the Soldiers of Coroticus, saw the bishop of Ireland’s invectives against their local warlord to be a territorial infringement. How dare the oddball bishop of Ireland admonish a prominent citizen of Christian Britain? Patrick’s jurisdiction was with the barbarians of Ireland, and if some Irish were killed and kidnapped by an important Romano-British chieftain, Patrick had to understand that this was just the way business was being conducted in the 400s.
It was probably Patrick’s Letter to the Soldiers of Coroticus, then, that got him summoned to Britain to account for his actions. And following whatever chastisement he endured from the Romano-British Christian establishment, Patrick wrote his Confession. In the Confession, we’ve already seen Patrick’s admissions of his moral imperfection and his limitations with Latin. But the Confession also shows Patrick as someone who felt like he was treated as a lesser among equals. He writes in a moving, simple passage,
Listen to me well, all of you, great and small, everyone who has any fear of God – especially you wealthy landowners so proud of your education – listen and consider this carefully: God chose foolish little me from among all of you who seem so wise and so expert in the law and so powerful in your eloquence. He picked ignorant Patrick ahead of all of you – even though I am not worthy – he picked me to go forth with fear and reverence, and without any complaining at the time – to serve the Irish faithfully. (145)
The meaning here is pretty clear. Patrick wasn’t a fancy person. There was a lot he didn’t know. At the same time, he knew that he’d had a calling to go to Ireland, and that once he went there, things worked.
It’s hard to tell exactly what sort of blowback Patrick faced from the church leaders of Britain. There was the news of his youthful transgression that seemed to suddenly be in wide circulation. But if we read the end of his Confession very carefully, we begin to get a sense that Patrick’s adversaries were trying to drum up misconduct charges against him, and not quite succeeding. Earlier, we learned that one of the unique challenges of Patrick’s ministry was that he had to pay protection money for safe conduct through certain parts of Ireland. This was an unusual church expense, and for a Romano-British establishment already prejudiced against barbarian Ireland, Patrick’s habit of paying to proselytize, so to speak, seems to have garnered negative attention.
Another matter of controversy, however, is that Patrick seems to have been hesitant to accept gifts from his wealthier Irish congregants. Patrick writes that some women in his congregation “have been known to offer me small gifts and to place their jewelry on the altar as an offering, but I always returned it to them. They were shocked that I wouldn’t accept these gifts” (147). Patrick’s Romano-British counterparts may have learned of this refusal and been put off by it. To be fair to Patrick’s critics, the church was bolstered by gifts from wealthy benefactors – that was one of its main sources of funding, and so having a maverick over in Ireland refusing to accept barbarian money to fund his own work would have made Patrick seem like an exceptionalist in their eyes. Patrick’s opponents may have even thought he should be sending some of his congregation’s donations over to them in Roman Britain. However, in the Confession Patrick also explains why he won’t take money from his wealthy Irish parishioners. He writes “I have to take the long-term view on this. I have to be very careful in these matters or some non-Christian might see it as an opportunity to criticize me and my ministry here. I cannot afford to give anyone even the smallest excuse to accuse me or defame my work” (147). In other words, Patrick explains to his critics, the optics of accepting gifts from wealthier Irish congregants would be very poor. His position there was delicate, and he didn’t want any chiefs or kingpins to think he was a swindler.
The Confession, intermittently self-effacing, ends with tempered self-assurance. Patrick tells his readers he will keep doing what he’s been doing, including paying money for protection in order to evangelize. He’d spent an enormous sum in order to travel around the island with legal permission to do so, he admits, but also says he’s not sorry for it, and that he’ll continue to spend whatever he needs in order to keep the momentum of his ministry going. The letter comes to its close with a final plea that ultimately showcases Patrick’s absolute dedication to his work in Ireland. He writes that if he’s ever done a fruitful thing for God, his prayer is that he’ll be able to die in Ireland among the slaves and converts of his community. He can be interred, Patrick says, in a grave with no markings, or left to be eaten by scavengers – it doesn’t matter to him. He just wants to tend to his people, and do his work as long as he can. [music]
Patrick in Later Hagiographies
The Saint Patrick that most of human history has known is a different person than the one whom we have met in this episode. The real Patrick lived so early, and inspired so many legends, that he’s been turned into a snake charmer and general emblem of Ireland, rather than the actual human about whom primary sources survive. The reason for this transformation is that from the early medieval period onward, Saint Patrick inspired a mountainous quantity of biographical writings – writings that, through the telephone game of history, had turned into wholesale fiction within a few centuries after he died. Even by the time of the 9th century Book of Armagh, one of the earliest repositories of Old Irish – though the bulk of it is in Latin – Patrick had become the center of a number of legends and early saint’s lives. An early hagiography partially survives in the Book of Armagh, written by a monk named Muirchú very roughly around 700. Muirchú was aware that he was writing the life of a person who’d been gone for 200 years, and he admitted,Lest. . .I be seen as making much out of [a] little, I will proceed. . .to relate one at a time these few deeds of the many [performed by] Saint Patrick, [albeit] with [only] scant tradition, unreliable sources, a fading memory, a debilitated intelligence, and a vile style – but with a most reverent feeling of love, obeying the command of [God’s] sanctity and authority.18
It’s a fascinating moment in medieval historical writing – a momentary display of self-consciousness in which Muirchú admits that he’s relying on a scrap heap of hearsay and imperfect documents. Muirchú’s biography was early within a long a tradition of storytelling about Saint Patrick, a tradition which, over the course of a thousand years after he died, took the Patrick of the Confessions, a Late Antique churchman, and transformed into a superhero and demigod.
Saint Patrick in a photograph (c. 1890-1910) of a woodcut print of unknown origins. The radiant bishop’s mitre and flock of anachronistically dressed devotees are pretty different from what Patrick’s hardscrabble ministry in Ireland would have actually looked like.
The Tripartite Life of Patrick, again, again an anonymous work that came together between 800 and 1100 or so, is mostly a machine gun of miracle stories. These miracle stories stud Patrick’s biography from the cradle to the grave. The Tripartite Life tells us that when he was born, there was no water to baptize him, and so he wiggled his fingers in the shape of the cross and water came to the town well and the previously blind priest there could see again. The book claims that “[T]he flagstone whereon he was born, when any one commits perjury under it, pours forth water as if it were bewailing he false testimony.”19 As an infant, the Tripartite Life alleges, Patrick stopped a flood, and caused icicles to burn when wood was needed. As a child, he turned water into healing honey.
The Tripartite Life pads out the early part of Patrick’s life story extensively, telling us that Patrick’s parents were killed in a raid in Strathclyde, and he was kidnapped from this specific region of Britain, along with his sisters, whose names were Lupait and Tigris. The hagiography minimizes the previous bishop of Ireland’s role there, telling us that Palladius “baptized a few in that place, and founded three churches” (31), but that was about it, and then claims that Patrick went to Rome to speak directly to the Pope to seek out a bishopric in Ireland. And when Patrick arrived in Ireland, at least according to the Tripartite Life, a series of confrontations began between Patrick and the indigenous shamans of Ireland, confrontations about which later hagiographers loved to make up stories.
This might be one of the signature oddities of all later writings about Patrick. In this episode, just a few minutes ago, we learned that Patrick’s primary adversaries were, first of all, a British warlord named Coroticus and his soldiers, who killed and enslaved some of Patrick’s congregation, and second, unnamed colleagues within the Romano-British church who disparaged him and perhaps sought his ouster, and may have had some connection to the aforementioned Coroticus. You don’t have to read Patrick’s Confession or Letter too closely to see that – the whole point is that Patrick, at a late career moment, felt cornered and vilified by various powerful men in the dying world of Roman Britian. However, in the fiction that was later written about Patrick, his adversaries are not British pirates and prelates, but instead a cartoonish lineup of Irish scoffers, among them a kings and wizards.
One of the longer and more lurid episodes in the Tripartite Life chronicles Patrick’s showdown with an Irish king and that king’s magicians. A king, the hagiography tells us, ruled in Ireland named Loegaire, and “This cruel king. . .had wizards and enchanters who used to foretell by their wizardry and heathenism what was before them. . .they were the authors of that art of false prophecy. They foretold. . .that an evil-lawed prophet would come hither over sea to their land and teach. . .and that he would find love and reverence with the men of Ireland” (33). These wizards, the hagiography tells us, had it in for Patrick from the beginning.
An early altercation is one of the most climactic in the book. During an Easter celebration, Patrick set up camp in a meadow that was sacred to pagan traditions. Patrick lit a fire there to celebrate Easter before the polytheists customarily lit their fires, and thus incurred the wrath of a local king and his sorcerers. When the king and his posse confronted Patrick, he spoke a bible verse and one man-of-arms converted immediately. Later, a wizard told Patrick that the Trinity was a false invention, Patrick said a prayer, and the wizard flew up into the air, and then was driven down so hard onto the air that his brains splashed out of his head and his body flew to pieces.
Evidently undaunted by this act of brutality, a different sorcerer mocked the notion of Mary’s virginity. Patrick made the sign of the cross and the earth swallowed this idolator. The Irish king present on the scene had seen enough. The king himself told his men to kill Patrick, as Patrick was murdering the native Irishmen. Patrick voiced a curse, and darkness billowed over the sun. The earth shook, and the Irishmen, muddled by Patrick’s spell, attacked one another until fifty of them were dead. The king, however, even after this escalation of violence, still refused to convert.
Though immediate hostilities ceased, and some time passed, this king continued to have Patrick in his crosshairs. A court wizard tried to poison Patrick, and failed. Then, out in a meadow, an outright miracle competition ensued. The Irish wizards made it snow, but Patrick made the snow vanish. The Irish wizards made it dark, and Patrick made it light again. There was talk of throwing their respective holy books in water and fire and seeing which books would survive, but the Irish wizards didn’t think they had a chance of winning this. Then Patrick proposed standing in a house while it burned down and seeing whether a Christian in his entourage, or one of the pagan wizards would survive. The Irish sorcerers agreed to the contest, and although the Irish cheated, making sure that their half of the house was damp and built with green timber, Patrick’s disciple survived while the Irish sorcerer burned to death. The story of this confrontation in the Tripartite Life of Patrick concludes with the following paragraph:
The King became even much more enraged with Patrick for killing his wizard. He arose and wished to kill him at once, but, through Patrick’s intercession, God permitted him not. Thereafter God’s anger fell on the impious people, so that a great multitude of them perished, to wit, twelve thousand in one day. (59)
The mass killing of his subjects led to the king converting out of fear. And due to the insincerity of the king’s conversion, Patrick said that the king’s son would never have children. So ends the first part of the Tripartite Life of Saint Patrick.
Patrick addresses an unspecified monarch of Ireland in this 1348 illustration. Ireland did not have a king in the fifth century, but later saint’s lives invented various bigwigs whom Patrick confronted and triumphed over.
Scholar Rosalind Love calls hagiography “that most prolific of all medieval literary genres.”20 She’s not exaggerating. Love them or hate them, saint’s lives were produced on an industrial scale during the Middle Ages, and so someone like Patrick, one of the patron saints of Ireland, was going to have a lot of stuff written about him. What is true about Patrick’s hagiography is true about the genre in general. In terms of offering reliable historical information about the saints whom they purport to chronicle, most hagiographies have little value. They are formulaic, generally being conveyer belts of miracle stories, and they disregard the real ingenuity and soft skills of those they profess to chronicle, replacing these qualities with magic tricks. The Saint Patrick of the Tripartite Life is a stoic demigod who seems to think nothing of the killing of 12,000 Irish people. The Saint Patrick whom we learned about in this episode, by contrast, was a diligent, compromising networker smart enough to have a long, successful career, and who turned the other cheek, and sought to help Irish people rather than launching them into the air and smashing their brains out.
You have to deal with hagiography if you study the Middle Ages, and we’ll return to the genre a lot in upcoming shows. Sometimes, saint’s lives are unappealing in their harsh partisanship. Sometimes, even more drearily, they seem to be power fantasies for a clerical class who often lacked it and sought to imagine an alternate reality in which Christian luminaries destroyed rivals and stopped women from having sex. As with Saint Patrick’s hagiographies, the genre takes the moral complexity of real people who negotiated, failed, tried again, and grinded on, and slathers them with a clumsy lacquer of good and evil and superpowers. But hagiography, while it’s often of little value in recording the past that came before it, is still invaluable in serving as a portrait of its own present times.
As a literary scholar, when I look at something like the Tripartite Life, I would be pretty comfortable calling it a novel. It’s not a good novel, and it’s obviously been worked on by a lot of different people, but all the same, it is an extended work of fiction that happens to have some loose ties to an earlier historical period. Those who wrote it were more influenced by medieval Irish literature than they were the Late Antique world in which Patrick lived. In medieval Irish literature, there are druids and wizards all over the place working all kinds of magic. In medieval Irish literature, including works that we’ll read over the next few months, civilizational clashes unfold on plains and meadows, in which sorcery and violence momentously decide the future of Ireland. The real bards and druids whom Patrick would have actually met would have been normal indigenous intellectuals fluent in oral history and law. He probably did meet some pagan bigots opposed to Christian evangelism. He probably also met some who appreciated his humanitarian work among the poor and outcast of Ireland. But more than anything, his encounters with druids would have been with professional civil servants who were too busy to care much about little proletariat communes of monotheists. The real story of Late Antiquity, as we know from our long season on it, is far more a tale of integration and gradual change than Armageddon. Literary trends of the later Middle Ages encouraged saint’s lives that were full of large-scale violence, magic, and other special effects. But the real Patrick, as you now understand, didn’t need any of this silly stuff to be a saint.
Moving on to Early Irish Literature
Now that we have a grasp on who Saint Patrick was and the world in which he lived, it’s time to turn our attention more broadly to early medieval Ireland. What kind of a civilization did Saint Patrick encounter when he stepped off of a boat there, in chains, at some point during the 400s? After Patrick was gone, how did Christianity continue expand there during the poorly documented 400s, 500s, and 600s, in a territory that had no urban centers to seat bishops, and no Roman aristocrats to ascend to managerial positions in the church? In our next program, Episode 132: The Beginnings of Irish Literature, we’re going to answer these questions, and also learn about how and why vernacular literature began being written down in Irish very early during European history. This next show will include some of the earliest poems that survive in the Irish language, and in it, we’ll kick off a deep dive into early medieval Irish literature. In America, even though a metric ton of us have Irish roots, I don’t think we know much about this literature, with its trademark combination of Celtic mythology, native Irish epic tradition, Christianity, and the occasional dash of Greco-Roman influence, too. Over the next twenty or so hours of the show, though, I’m going to do my best to teach a big section of this literature directly from the primary sources, and I hope, if I do a good job and you tell a few people about what you’ve learned, that all of these upcoming stories we’ll read will become a bit better known.There’s a quiz on this program available on the podcast website – link to that quiz available in the notes of this show in your podcast player. If you want to hear a song I wrote about Saint Patrick, stay on – otherwise, see you soon!
Still here? So, I got to thinking. Listen, I’ve read a lot of hagiography. The first graduate seminar I ever took was taught by a prominent scholar on hagiography – she’s awesome. But to me, it’s a tough genre, for reasons that I discussed and perhaps maybe in this episode – basically that saint’s lives are generally tacky comic strips that misrepresent the real people they chronicle. I got to thinking about that, and I started wondering what would happen if the historical Saint Patrick stepped up to an open mic night with an acoustic guitar. What if Patrick stepped up there, and started telling his life story, and then, some hagiographers interrupted it? Hagiographers who thought they could do a better job? I got to thinking about that, and I wrote this tune, which is called “Saint Patrick and the Hagiographers.” I hope you like it, and I’ll see you next time.
“Saint Patrick and the Hagiographers” [song]
References
2.^ Jocelin. The Life and Acts of Saint Patrick. Hibernia Press Company, 1809, p. 187.
3.^ Zosimus. New History (VI). Printed in Delphi Complete Works of Zosimus. Delphi Classics, 2023, p. 247. Further references to this text will be noted with page numbers in this episode transcription.
4.^ Freeman (2004), p. 13.
5.^ Freeman (2004), p. 176.
6.^ Strabo. Geography (4.5.4). Printed in Strabo. Complete Works of Strabo. Delphi Classics, 2016. Kindle Edition, Location 5353.
7.^ Jerome. Against Jovinianus (2.7). Printed in Jerome. The Complete Works of Saint Jerome. Public Domain, 2016, p. 876. The Attacotti Jerome mentions might have been from Scotland or Ireland – Jerome himself probably didn’t know.
8.^ Printed in Collins, Roger. Early Medieval Europe 300-1000. Red Globe Press, 2010, p. 243.
9.^ See Downham, Clare. Medieval Ireland. Cambridge University Press, 2018, p. 17.
10.^ See Downham (2018), p. 18.
12.^ See Freeman (2004), p. 63.
13.^ See Freeman (2004), p. 69.
14.^ Comentarii de Bello Gallico (6.13-14). Printed in Julius Caesar: Complete Works. Delphi Classics, 2013. Kindle Edition, Locations 2027-45.
15.^ Bello Gallico (6.14-20).
16.^ See Freeman (2004), p. 112.
17.^ See Freeman (2004), p. 140.
18.^ Nagy, Joseph Falaky. Conversing with Angels and Ancients: Literary Myths of Medieval Ireland. Cornel University Press, 1997, p. 41.
19.^ Anonymous. The Tripartite Life of Saint Patrick with Other Documents Relating to that Saint. Edited with Translations by Whitley Stokes. Eyre and Spottiswoode, 1887, p. 9. Further quotes from this text will be noted parenthetically in this episode transcription.
20.^ Love, Rosalind. “Insular Latin literature to 900.” Printed in Printed in Lees, Clare A., et. al., eds. The Cambridge History of Early Medieval English Literature. Cambridge University Press, 2013, p. 127.
